Nursing Homes in New Castle, IN

Nursing Homes in New Castle, IN

5 Medicare-certified nursing homes in New Castle, Indiana are rated below using federal CMS inspection records, staffing levels, deficiency citations, and resident quality outcomes — translated into plain English. Average safety score: 74/100. Scores updated monthly. Most listed facilities are in Henry County.

4 facilities score Strong Safety Record or Generally Positive.

Data source and freshness

These New Castle scores are generated from public CMS Care Compare and Provider Data Catalog records. Data is refreshed monthly; this page was generated in May 2026.

Use scores as a starting point

A safety score can narrow your list, but families should still review recent citations, ask administrators direct questions, and tour before choosing care.

Download the nursing home tour checklist
5
Medicare-certified facilities
74/100
Average safety score
4
Strong or generally positive
0
Serious or critical findings
382
Certified beds represented

Safety score distribution in New Castle

Generally Positive 4
Use Caution 1

This distribution helps families avoid relying on a single average. A city can have a reasonable average score while still containing individual facilities that deserve closer review.

Local safety snapshot

Use this New Castle list to compare facilities before a tour or hospital discharge decision. Open individual reports to review inspection citations, staffing, enforcement actions, quality outcomes, and questions to ask administrators.

Top-scoring in New Castle

  1. Waters Of New Castle, The — 81/100
  2. Glen Oaks Health Campus — 79/100
  3. Hickory Creek At New Castle — 74/100

Facilities to review carefully

  1. Willows Of New Castle — 65/100
Generally Positive (4) Use Caution (1)
Facility Name Score Rating Beds
Waters Of New Castle, The 81 Generally Positive 66
Glen Oaks Health Campus 79 Generally Positive 68
Hickory Creek At New Castle 74 Generally Positive 36
Stonebrooke Rehabilitation Center 72 Generally Positive 117
Willows Of New Castle 65 Use Caution 95

Compare nearby Indiana cities

Indianapolis 44 facilities, avg 68/100 Fort Wayne 26 facilities, avg 73/100 Evansville 17 facilities, avg 69/100 Muncie 11 facilities, avg 68/100 South Bend 10 facilities, avg 69/100 Terre Haute 9 facilities, avg 67/100 Carmel 8 facilities, avg 76/100 Elkhart 8 facilities, avg 69/100 Nursing Homes in Anderson, IN Nursing Homes in Avon, IN Nursing Homes in Bedford, IN Nursing Homes in Bloomington, IN Nursing Homes in Carmel, IN Nursing Homes in Clarksville, IN Nursing Homes in Columbus, IN Nursing Homes in Elkhart, IN Nursing Homes in Evansville, IN Nursing Homes in Fort Wayne, IN

Frequently Asked Questions — New Castle Nursing Homes

How many nursing homes are in New Castle?

Senior Care Report Card lists 5 Medicare-certified nursing homes in New Castle, Indiana, with safety scores based on federal CMS inspection, staffing, enforcement, and quality data.

What is the average nursing home safety score in New Castle?

The average Senior Care Safety Score for listed New Castle facilities is 74/100. Use the individual facility reports to compare the reasons behind each score.

How should families use this New Castle nursing home list?

Use the table to shortlist facilities, then read each report's deficiency citations, staffing levels, penalties, and quality outcomes. Scores are a research starting point, not medical or legal advice.

Compare all 5 nursing homes in New Castle, Indiana

Each report includes inspection history, deficiency citations, staffing data, penalty records, and resident quality outcomes — all pulled from CMS Care Compare and translated into a 0–100 safety score. Scores are informational and are not medical, legal, or placement advice.

View all nursing homes in Indiana →