ATLANTICARE MANAGEMENT LLC
BREWSTER, NY · Putnam County · For profit - Limited Liability company · 160 certified beds
📍 46 Mt Ebo Road North, Brewster, NY 10509 · 📞 (845) 278-3636
Medicare ID: 335824 · Last Medicare inspection: Sep 29, 2025
Score Breakdown
What the numbers mean
ATLANTICARE MANAGEMENT LLC scored 47 out of 100 — 20 points below the state average of 67.
📋 Inspections: 35 citations over the last 36 months — 23 more than the state average (12). 1 was rated serious (G+) — an inspector determined it caused or risked harm to a resident. 2 findings recurred across inspection cycles — indicating a problem that was not fixed.
⚠️ Staffing: Staffing levels are below average. Lower staffing is associated with longer response times, more pressure injuries, and higher hospitalization rates. Ask the facility directly about their RN-to-resident ratio and how they handle shortfalls.
⚖️ Penalties & enforcement: No significant federal fines or enforcement actions on record — a positive indicator of consistent regulatory compliance.
⚠️ Complaints: Above-average complaint activity. Complaint surveys are unannounced and targeted — they often surface problems that routine annual inspections miss. Ask management about the nature of complaints filed and how each was resolved.
⚠️ Resident quality outcomes: Some quality measures are below national benchmarks. Areas like fall prevention, pain management, or medication use may warrant closer attention.
What inspectors found (last 3 surveys)
Top concern areas
⚖ Penalties & Enforcement
Federal civil monetary penalties (CMPs) are only issued after a facility has failed two levels of regulatory review — meaning problems were found on inspection and the facility could not rebut the findings. This is a serious escalation beyond a standard citation.
📅 Per-action enforcement records (date, fine amount, and penalty type for each individual action) are sourced from a separate CMS enforcement dataset and will be added in a future data update.
Resident Wellbeing — Key Indicators
These are the measures families ask about most. They come from CMS clinical assessments of every resident — not just inspection reports. Stars (★) count toward the official CMS quality star rating.
Source: CMS MDS Quality Measures & Medicare claims data. Scores shown are the most recent 4-quarter averages for long-stay residents.
See every citation, score history, ownership, and get monthly alerts
Watch this facility for $14.99/year. Family plan covers 3 facilities for $29.99/year.